Artifact Technical Committee
Artifact Evaluation

Quality badges

Each artifact can earn up to four badges, assigned independently by the review committee according to the requirements met.

Available

Code and/or data available in a stable, public repository.

Requirements

  • Available in a stable repository (GitHub, GitLab, ...).
  • A README.md with the minimum requirements present in the repository.

Functional

The artifact can be executed and the reviewer observes its functionality.

Requirements

  • List of dependencies and their versions.
  • Description of the execution environment.
  • Installation and execution instructions.
  • A minimal execution example.

Sustainable

Modular, organized, intelligible, and easy-to-understand code.

Requirements

  • Minimal code documentation (files, functions, ...).
  • Minimal code readability.
  • Lets evaluators identify the paper's main claims within the artifact.

Reproducible

The paper's main claims can be reproduced by the reviewer.

Requirements

  • Instructions to run the main claims (figures/tables).
  • A description of how the experiments were run.
  • Scripts that automate reproduction are suggested (VMs, containers).
Instructions — submission, review, and README examples — versioned and used by every edition of the year. Read instructions →